Skip to content
VertexView

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: Artemisia Gentileschi’s Electrifying Mary Magdalene.

A woman throws her head backwards. Lids sealed, lips sealed, yet she is awake and aware. With rosy cheeks and crimson lips, her long honey-colored hair is illuminated by the light from a flickering flame, casting a radiant aura in an predominantly dark chamber. She wears includes a delicate blouse—slipping down one shoulder to expose alabaster skin—to a heavy gold and violet cloth. Seemingly alone, unaware of any observer, dwelling in a state of profound freedom.

An Important Institutional First

The subject is Mary Magdalene depicted in ecstasy, painted in the seventeenth century by Artemisia Gentileschi. Freshly purchased by the National Gallery of Art in the U.S. capital, it is set to go on display from 24 February. It represents the institution’s maiden purchase of a work by the artist, and expert a leading scholar has noted that it shows the religious figure as “neither repentant nor suffering”. This is an crucial difference, for generations, Magdalene’s depiction has been shaped not only by scripture but fabulated and conflated by influential men.

“The most versatile character in religious painting,” as one expert stated.

Examine images of her and you encounter a thinker, orator, disciple, and witness; weeping at the base of the Cross, anointing Christ’s feet, or gazing toward the sky—often repenting with shimmering tears and, too often, revealing her chest. Sometimes recognized by a ointment vessel or a red robe—a contrast to the Virgin Mary’s azure—she is most popularly known nowadays as Christ’s lover, despite no biblical verse labeling her as such.

Unraveling the Historical Figure

“The truth is, we do not truly know who she was,” noted the scholar. “Consequently, numerous layers of meaning have been placed upon her. The transformations she experiences, both in art but narratively, in worship, in doctrine, are as closely tied to cultural attitudes and religious changes as they are to faith.” So what do we know?

She is mentioned in the New Testament 12 times. The first, she has evil spirits expelled from her; the rest, she is seen at the execution and is the first person to experience his rising. It is she who spreads the “good news”. The sensual and immoral reputation can mostly be traced to a homily given in the late sixth century by Pope Gregory the Great, who merged her with Mary of Bethany and an anonymous woman who bathed Christ’s feet with her tears.

In collapsing them together, he effectively “invented” the repentant prostitute—a myth further elaborated by subsequent church fathers and medieval legends. Painters and sculptors took note, and in a largely non-reading but visually literate world, this was highly impactful. Her “seven demons” became the “seven deadly sins”, cementing her primary narrative as one of moral lapse and later redemption—solidified in paintings and sculptures that still shape perceptions today.

Centuries of Penitence and Objectification

From Donatello’s emaciated, skeletal figure clasping her hands in penitence, to Caravaggio’s 1606 depiction of her drained of color and on the brink of death—not to mention Rubens’ partially clothed, rapturous saint supported by angels. Her image has frequently been diminished through objectification. Albrecht Dürer’s engraving presented her demurely, with flowing hair covering her unclothed body, while Titian’s version gazes upward, with tearful eyes and carefully placed hands revealing her breasts.

It seems, suffering and sexualization were the dominant extremes in her representation: she could act as a cautionary tale against transgression, be the poster girl for repentance, while providing artists a pretext to paint the female form masked as devotion. This “penitent prostitute” narrative persisted for centuries—so deeply that institutions called “Magdalene asylums” forced women into unpaid labor, systems that astonishingly ended just thirty years ago.

Through a Woman’s Eyes

But what if there was another side to her story? What if her tale could be one of enlightenment and metamorphosis, where she was pictured as vibrant, joy, and transcendence? Essentially, what if we saw her via the lens of a female artist?

That is what Artemisia achieves. This portrait is not posing for the viewer; she is without tears, not repenting, without shame, not sexualized, and not preaching a sermon. Instead, she sports rosy cheeks and is, according to notes, “passionately alive … in the throes of divine joy”. An expert stated that Gentileschi “imbues Mary Magdalene with an electrifying vitality”.

“Yes, it’s an ecstasy painting, but it’s not her moment of repentance. It’s a moment of divine meeting … spoken of sometimes as if it’s the finest physical experience … the greatest orgasm she could ever have. It’s aesthetic, it’s bodily, it’s sexual, it’s spiritual. One is raised beyond oneself to a higher level.”

Frequently, when female artists depict biblical or legendary women, they present them not as submissive, guilty, ashamed, or inferior, but as active, multifaceted, and with wills of their own: “Women with a capital ‘W’”.

Part of a Broader Cultural Movement

Thus, while this recent Gentileschi might ultimately be correcting a representational imbalance at the institution, its importance extends further. It alters not only how we view religious and mythological women, but also the understanding of womanhood in general.

This view is one the Catholic church in time recognized. In 1969, it formally recognized Magdalene’s official role as a devoted disciple rather than a sinful repenter. More recently 2016, Pope Francis raised her ranking to “the apostle of apostles”, designating 22 July as her feast day. It seems that, while establishments change, viewpoints are shifting. This acquisition—of a woman liberated from a male perspective, existing for herself, not suffering nor sensationalised—is a component in a larger movement towards a more balanced representation.

PP
By

Patrick Porter MD

A digital strategist with over a decade of experience in tech consulting and data-driven innovation.

VertexView

Type to search articles.